Bright Star Real Estate Logo

Country Oasis - Home, Shop, & Ponds: 15 acres

1408 W 1250 N, Milford, Indiana 46542
August 17, 2023, 6:00 pm
Owner: James & Marlene Bontrager
SOLD FOR $505,000

Phone bid auction ends on Thursday, August 17th at 6 p.m.
Open House
: Thursdays (July 20, July 27, August 3, August 10) from 4 to 6 p.m., or by appt.
Starting Bid: $450,000

Experience comfortable living in this two-story house with ample windows to let in fresh breezes during the day and a cozy gas fireplace in the hearth in the evenings. The property also includes a versatile two-story shop with an apartment and a ground floor shop, providing investment potential or flexible living arrangements, all with efficient heating and cooling systems for year-round comfort.


Fifteen acres featuring two stocked ponds, a charming windmill for aeration, and a delightful firepit area for outdoor gathering: you'll be sure to experience both relaxation and recreation at this property. The lush landscape is adorned with fruitful apple and cherry trees, while a garden with raised strawberry boxes awaits your green thumb. For hunting enthusiasts, you'll have the opportunity to make use of the included treestand.



House (3 bds, 2 bths)
  • Two stories
  • Primary bedroom, en suite with jacuzzi bathtub
  • Hearth with gas fireplace
  • Geothermal heating & cooling
  • Garage with large storage room
  • New roof
Shop & Second Story Apartment
  • 24' x 40', two stories
  • Second story apartment (1 bd, 1 bth) with full kitchen
  • Ground floor shop with office
  • Heating & cooling


Terms: 5% down day of auction, non-refundable. Balance due at closing in approximately 30 days. Statements made day of auction supersede printed statements. Property to sell per seller’s confirmation.

For more information call Jesse Riegsecker at (574) 612-7277 or email


Listing Contact

Jesse Riegsecker
(574) 612-7277

Share This Listing

Bright Star Real Estate Logo
55137 State Road 13, Middlebury, Indiana 46540
Phone - (574) 821-7653
Realtor LogoNAA Auctioneer LogoCAI LogoIAA LogoBBB Logo
A Licensed Real Estate Company in Indiana and Michigan

Auctioneer Licenses

Auctioneer Co. Lic. - Bright Star Realty & Auctions, LLC - AC32100007
Auctioneer Lic. - Loren Beachy - AU10500161